The shifting economics california
this is california the golden state and
one of the largest economies in the
world
in its own right if california was
counted as a sovereign nation
it would be the fifth largest by gdp
with a 3.2 trillion dollar gross
state product putting it just behind
germany and just ahead
of india of course the state has a lot
going for it
from the largest movie and technology
centers in the world
all the way to a surprisingly strong
agricultural sector
all of this has meant that the residents
of california are on average
doing very well for themselves and one
look around the wealthy enclaves of los
angeles and san francisco
would back this assumption up despite
all of this however
the state is going through a period of
economic turbulence
the fallout of the coronavirus has hit
the state’s economy
particularly hard major industries like
tourism and media creation
have ground to a complete halt having
widespread knock-on implications
and hitting a lot of smaller vendors who
were once reliant on these industries
this bump in the road however was by no
means the total undoing of the state
california’s metrics before 2020 looked
very strong with low unemployment solid
growth and booming industries
but there were still cracks forming
the state is home to the largest
population in the us
but the industries that were truly
driving wealth creation
are famously bad at actually employing
people
this had led to a sharp increase in
social issues like homelessness
and crime all of these problems that
were once bubbling away under the
surface have now been massively
accelerated
so much so that many economists have
predicted that the sun might be sitting
on the sunshine state
now that may sound like absurdist
alarmism but it’s a reality that
shouldn’t be totally dismissed
remember in previous decades there was
another economic region in the us
riding the high of a new growth industry
but these days
detroit is not exactly seen as the
bastion of prosperity
it once was so could the same grim
reality be in store for california
well to answer this we need to look at a
few key
areas what made the state so prosperous
before the 2020 downturn
what were the underlying issues
impacting the economy
how will these issues be impacted by the
wider economic decline
and finally while we are at it we may as
well give it an ee national economy
score and put it on the leaderboard
i know i know it’s a state but with a
gdp in the trillions of dollars
it certainly deserves an entry this
video was brought to you by trends
what’s trends ah i’m glad you asked
trends
is the internet’s ultimate knowledge hub
for entrepreneurs
investors and startup ceos it’s the
brainchild of the hustle
the free to read email newsletter read
by over a
million people every morning stay tuned
until the end to learn more
or pause the video and go to trends.co
slash ee
where you can try trends for two weeks
all for just one dollar
now that’s a deal trends dot co
slash ee the link is on the screen now
and in the video description
below now this year has certainly been
one for doom
and gloom but it is still important to
address what is working well
any economy that can grow to the level
that california has
and provides so much wealth and
prosperity to its citizens
is probably doing something right so
what was the driver of the californian
dream
california is both really lucky and
really
unlucky in terms of its geography the
state had a big head start over other
states in the union when it was getting
started because
it had access to decent farmland a good
year-round climate
oh and an ocean for fishing and trade
on the flip side of that coin it was
literally about as far
away from the economic centers in the
u.s as one could reasonably get
while still within the u.s nonetheless
the state grew well as a distant outpost
that attracted farmers gold diggers and
or people that would rather be a little
bit removed from all of that pesky
law and order in the east the first big
win for the state in the modern era
was its film industry which was
curiously also at least partially thanks
to its geography
and position in the world you see early
film technology relied heavily on lots
of light and good weather
that’s one thing that california has in
abundance
i mean it’s right there in the name
what’s more
is that a lot of this new cinema was
filmed using technologies that
had patents on them primarily patents
owned by thomas edison and his
businesses that were headquartered
in new york by conducting business in
los angeles
up-and-coming film companies felt more
comfortable not being found out for
using much cheaper film equipment that
was not paying royalties back to edison
for his patterns now this all meant two
things
for starters it hopefully makes you feel
a little bit less guilty about watching
a cheeky movie for free online
but more importantly it established la
as the center of the movie business
we actually plan to do an entire video
on the economics of hollywood
but for now just know that eventually of
course camera technology got to a point
where film locations were not as
important and
modern studios do pay what they owe to
their suppliers
but once these studios were established
they got comfortable
support industries sprung up
film-related unions were founded and it
almost got to a point where it was
really hard to film anywhere
but la so through nothing but being in
the right place at the right time and
turning a blind eye some 100 years ago
california is now the epicenter of one
of the largest industries in the world
this would go on to become a common
theme the tech revolution that has
started silicon valley
was mostly formed around stanford
university which was one of the first
universities in the nation
to offer computer science as a course
once a few companies got going
other tech companies were attracted to
the same area and along with them came
people with expertise to create new
technology
once this modern gold rush hit a
critical mass silicon valley
just became the logical place to conduct
tech business because
it naturally ticked all the boxes access
to suppliers
access to investors and access to
skilled workers
given that technical development by its
very nature can be virtually rolled out
anywhere
being in and amongst a huge pool of
competitors is not as much of an issue
as it would be for customer facing
industries like
retail hospitality or even manufacturing
in fact having this ecosystem actually
makes everything much easier
you need a part that only a niche tech
manufacturer in the world makes
good chance it will be in silicon valley
you need to consult with the world
leader in some type of technical
infrastructure
chances are silicon valley is the place
to find them
this whole process is called
agglomeration which is a fancy word for
the benefits an industry receives by
being geographically close to its
industry partners
and peers being lucky enough to just
happen to have the nuclei around which
the largest industry in the world formed
became par for the course for california
now a lot of this was good planning and
the state did a lot of things right to
nurture the growth of these industries
but luck did play an undoubtedly huge
part
all the same even if north dakota
happened to be the early center for
technical innovation
it’s hard to see it having the same
appeal to tech companies and their staff
as the blue skies and sandy beaches of
california
now so far this all sounds great
california has a diverse portfolio of
wealth creating industries that are not
dependent on limited resources to
sustain
but suffering from success does start to
become an issue
in its own right especially when
california
is home to a lot of people that don’t
call it home
for a lack of better way of putting it
welcome to the hotel california
gold rushers throughout history were not
good for local economies long term
they see a massive spike in new workers
all desperately seeking their riches and
this does create some short-term wins
businesses catering to this foot traffic
can be built and maybe even some taxes
can be levied
but once the gold is dug everything goes
right back to where it was now the
california gold rush is a distant memory
these days
however state is not immune to the same
effects
on a larger scale moving to la to try
and make it in the film industry or san
francisco
to earn fat stacks as a developer are
pretty common endeavors
the issue is that these types of
employment
don’t actually give too much back to the
economy an influx of computer
programmers getting paid six figures for
graduate positions
means that things like real estate
become unaffordable to long-term
residents that moved into
other industries real estate also drives
up rents for commercial buildings which
get passed along to consumers
as higher costs of living it would be
next to
impossible for a worker earning the
national average wage to move to the bay
area
and expect to live a comfortable
lifestyle even as a single adult
not to mention with a family so people
either make sacrifices
like living with roommates or parents or
they move away
now particularly cold-hearted viewers
might say that trading in some
average income earning local residents
for some exceptionally skilled
and well-compensated computer nerds is
probably a good trade to make
but it isn’t for starters you can’t run
a city on computer code
yet someone needs to be there to stock
the whole foods for all of these guys
and
unless produce packer is a job role that
starts to attract a six figure salary
these people need to be accommodated in
some way or else
demand pull inflation can get dangerous
very fast
but the real issue is that these people
don’t stay for long
san francisco has the highest level of
internal migration within the usa
that means lots of people are moving in
and lots of people are moving out
that’s because people working in silicon
valley don’t tend to do it for very long
a few years in the industry gets people
great experience and a nice big pile of
cash to take back to their home towns
during this time most of these workers
will live below their means and focus
pretty heavily on work
they won’t be living family lives that
give back to local industries because
well
it’s too expensive even these
well-compensated tech employees would
struggle to raise a family in southern
california
given the cost of living it’s a pretty
common industry game plan
graduate university get a job in a fang
company
stick it out for five years save up some
cash live in a tiny apartment
and then move back to your home city and
live like a king doing consultation work
so people paying a lot of money for a
short-term stay in modest comfort
i guess the hotel california is open for
business but
you can actually leave to try and make
the best of this bad situation the
california government levies the highest
state income taxes in the nation
the general idea is that sure these
outside workers can come and make their
millions but at least it will generate
lots of revenue for the government that
they can then use to address some of the
issues caused by said workers
now in theory this is fine and it
actually worked well for some time
but it was a precarious balancing act
the slightest breeze could throw it off
course which is
exactly where the hurricane that is 2020
came in
the hotel california for the first time
ever was starting to see
mass vacancies the economic fallout of
the coronavirus has been a major hit
to everybody but the consequences have
been
especially severe in the united states
and especially severe in california
for starters nobody is making a movie or
going on a beach holiday or attending
disneyland at the moment
so that has been a major direct blow
but what might end up being more severe
is the consequences that are a little
bit harder to notice
people are starting to leave
the push to work from home means that
the aforementioned tech workers
no longer need to live in a cramped
one-bedroom apartment in the bay area
they can instead just do exactly the
same thing in a nice family home
anywhere in the nation while enjoying a
much better quality of life
and paying much less in tax
that same income tax designed to make
the most of those high-income earners
while they were there
is now pushing more and more people away
the issue of capital flight is an
argument that is often brought up to
dissuade governments from passing laws
on high-income earners
to speak candidly most of the time these
arguments are weak at best
most people will not move their families
to a new nation to save a few thousand
dollars on taxes
but a single worker moving to a new city
in the same country
well that’s a far more compelling
prospect
in fact while i was in the process of
writing this script
graeme steffen a personal finance
youtuber posted a breakdown of exactly
why
he is leaving california and moving to
las vegas to live
now graham does not work in the tech
industry but
he is still indicative of those types of
workers
young well-off with a business that he
can do from anywhere
without a family of course one man’s
experience does not a trend make
but this reason for leaving was very in
line with the research that we conducted
so anyway go and check out that video
here’s a good egg that graham
okay i know california is not a country
and
this says national leaderboard but it’s
still interesting nonetheless and i mean
hong kong gets a spot so why not right
size is simply phenomenal california
would make for a huge
national economy in its own right but
the fact that it’s just one part of the
us
gives you an idea of just how
influential economies like the world’s
superpowers
really are it gets a 9 out of 10 of
course falling short of the
14 figure gdp club but still one of the
largest most influential economies
in the world gdp per capita is also very
high
as temperamental as they may be the
state is still home to a lot of very
skilled very industrious workers
and with that a gsp per capita of 72
000 in 2019 gets it a 9 out of 10.
curiously enough the state or territory
within the us with the highest gdp per
capita
is the district of columbia with a
whopping
162 000 as of 2008
which actually puts it in line with
places like monaco
stability and confidence this is really
subjective and had it been asked 12
months ago it would have been a clear 10
out of 10
but flying so high means that it has a
long way to fall
and it has historically felt the impacts
of downturns
more heavily than the national average
which is of course still very well
deserved for a state with such a diverse
portfolio
of world-leading industries growth is
pretty stable
the economy is large and reflects a
developed nation in its own right
and the growth figures reflect this as
well outside of 2020 it has averaged a
two to three percent growth rate over
the past few decades
so it gets a six out of ten finally
industry well come on what else could it
be
if anything could get an 11 out of 10 it
would be california for its industry but
in the meantime
it will need to make do with a nice
round 10 out of 10.
all together this gives the sunshine
state an average score of 8.4 out of 10
just falling short of the top spot of
course with the same big asterisks as
hong kong that this
is not actually a nation
california would be a remarkable economy
if it was its own
nation but in a way it’s even more so as
just a very productive piece of a
grander american puzzle
but that does not mean it’s not without
concern
yes it has been fortunate enough to
attract a lot of very profitable
businesses
and very skilled people that come with
them yes it’s lovely beaches and
attractions will continue to bring in
tourists and businesses alike
but it can’t rest on its laurels many
economies throughout history have
thought they were the epicenter of
industries that would last forever
became overly reliant on them and then
suffered as those same industries faded
into obscurity
there is no such thing as an unsinkable
ship and when all the smart people start
heading for the life rafts it might be
time to look out for icebergs ahead
who would have thought the golden child
of american industry would have been hit
so hard
in so many unusual ways in such a short
amount of time
it’s one of those events that you don’t
see happening until it’s too late
unless you have some fantastic insights
like the ones
provided by trends the internet’s
definitive knowledge hub for
entrepreneurs and aspiring ones alike
which reminds me question for you have
you ever wondered what internet
millionaires and gazillionaires all have
in common
hint they’re smart like really smart and
with a subscription to trends
you can be too trends gives you
exclusive access to the same information
that was previously only available to
hedge fund managers and high
achieving ceos we’re not only talking
about the internet’s best and most
exclusive content library
we’re talking about access access to
people
you would otherwise never be able to get
in front of
with a subscription to trends you can
also attend the live q a sessions hosted
by industry-leading entrepreneurs
as well as connect with other high
achievers both in real life
and digitally as warren buffett once
said the best investment you can ever
make
is in yourself try it out for two weeks
all for just one dollar